KINDS OF COURT PROCEEDINGS
AN OVERVIEW
A victim of domestic violence may be involved in various
kinds of court proceedings. The victim may be involved in only one
of the proceedings, all of the proceedings, or a combination at the same
time or different times. The different types of courts where proceedings
involving Domestic Violence issues may be heard are:
1. Criminal Court: The State files
a complaint against the batterer for committing a crime, i.e. spousal abuse,
battery, assault, terrorist threat etc. This may be misdemeanor or
a felony. Violation of a civil restraining order is also a crime.
In these actions, the State (the People) files a complaint against the
perpetrator and the victim of domestic violence is the VICTIM and the WITNESS.
2. Dependency Court: The State
(through the County) intervenes in cases of child abuse or neglect.
Usually a social worker from the Department of Family and Children Services
(DFCS) is contacted when a person from a public or private agency reports
domestic violence. A social worker may begin an investigation, and
inform the victim of domestic violence that her children will be removed
UNLESS she obtains restraining orders against the batterer. It is
important that she take all actions necessary to protect her children.
A social worker may recommend that a child be removed from the home of
the victim of domestic violence if the violence has occurred in front of
the children and/or if she refuses to obtain restraining orders against
the abuser. If the County files a petition to remove her child from her
home, she will be entitled to a court appointed attorney to represent her,
and so will all other parties, including the children.
3. Family Law Court: One party sues
the other, i.e. Jane Doe v. Jack Doe, for restraining orders and other
relief including but not limited to custody, visitation, child support.
The victim of domestic violence may obtain these orders by filing different
kinds of lawsuits, depending on her circumstances, as follows:
(a) a petition for relief under the Domestic Violence
Prevention Act (DVPA),
(b) a petition for Dissolution/Nullity of Marriage
or Legal Separation,
(c) a Petition to Establish the Parental Relationship
(unmarried parents).
It is with the proceedings that take
place in Family Law courts that these web pages concern themselves. Criminal
court and Juvenile court proceedings are beyond the topic of discussion
here.
KINDS OF FAMILY LAW
PROCEEDINGS: AN OVERVIEW
Family Law Court: One party sues the other, i.e. Jane Doe
v. Jack Doe, for restraining orders and other relief including but not
limited to custody, visitation, child support. The victim of domestic
violence may obtain these orders by filing different kinds of lawsuits,
depending on her/his circumstances, as follows:
(a) a petition for relief under the Domestic Violence
Prevention Act (DVPA),
(b) a petition for Dissolution/Nullity of Marriage
or Legal Separation,
(c) a Petition to Establish the Parental Relationship
(unmarried parents).
The Domestic Violence Prevention
Act (DVPA) is a summary proceeding that offers victims of domestic violence
quick access to the court. S/he can generally apply for and obtain and
temporary restraining order on the same day. The purpose of the DVPA is
to permit a battered person to obtain restraining orders, custody of children,
child support and other relief that will keep the battered person safe
and will provide stability until s/he can decide what s/he wants to do
next. S/he will have time to assess the situation, obtain support services
and place herself or himself in a position where s/he is financially and
emotionally able to seek other legal relief.
The advantages
of the DVPA are:
-
The procedures are comparatively straightforward and provide
a speedy resolution. You can get your temporary order on the same day you
apply;
-
Many victims are not emotionally or economically prepared
to file for dissolution/nullity/legal separation of marriage or petition
to establish parental relationship;
-
Some courts provide free Spanish interpreters;
-
A party may have a “support person” present at the hearing;
-
In the Central District, court trained providers may file
for DVPA temporary restraining orders by fax.
The disadvantages
of the DVPA are:
-
The batterer may file a superseding action (dissolution of
marriage, nullity, legal separation or action to establish parental relationship)
in another court. This is particularly true if the batterer has resources
and money to hire a lawyer. This may leave the battered person confused
and without legal assistance in a court that may be less sympathetic to
him/her;
-
Many courts do not make child support orders;
-
Some courts do not make custody orders;
-
Some courts are giving only limited time restraining orders
after hearing, i.e. 2-6 months;
-
Courts do not divide property (except very limited circumstances);
-
Courts cannot divorce people or order spousal support;
-
Courts cannot make a determination of who is the father if
that is contested.
Once a party has filed a Petition for Dissolution of Marriage,
Legal Separation or Nullity or a Petition to Establish the Parental Relationship,
the parties must generally file all other documents, including requests
for restraining orders, in that case at that courthouse. This is
generally true until after the judgment has been entered and the children,
if any, have reached the age of majority.